Skip to content
Federal Docket · EDVA

ActiveVideo kept its patent damages as an appeals court reversed the injunction

The Federal Circuit affirmed the damages award and interim royalty while overturning the permanent injunction in an interactive television dispute.

By Suffolk County Liberty Report Editorial DeskPublished
Albert V. Bryan United States Courthouse in Alexandria, Virginia.
Contextual image. Albert V. Bryan United States Courthouse in Alexandria, Virginia. dctim1. Image credits

ActiveVideo Networks and Verizon litigated competing patent claims involving interactive television technology in the Eastern District of Virginia. A jury heard evidence about whether Verizon’s accused system practiced claimed features. The jury awarded ActiveVideo $115 million. The district court later ordered an injunction, delaying its effect and setting a temporary royalty for the intervening period.

On appeal the Federal Circuit affirmed infringement findings on three ActiveVideo patents and reversed as to a fourth. It affirmed the damages award in full and upheld the temporary royalty. It reversed the permanent injunction after examining whether the claimed injury was connected to infringement and whether money damages could address the harm.

The Federal Circuit remanded for further proceedings and left the district court discretion over how to address prospective damages. The appeal shows the separate evidentiary requirements for an injunction and for money damages after a finding of infringement.