Skip to content
Investigations

Brightwaters trustees skipped advance review for $381,067 in payments

A state audit found that trustees missed routine checks on bills and the treasurer’s work. Village officials agreed with nine recommendations.

By Suffolk County Liberty Report Editorial DeskPublished
H. Lee Dennison County Executive Building in Hauppauge, New York.
Contextual image. H. Lee Dennison County Executive Building in Hauppauge, New York. Americasroof, perspective correction by Filetime. Image credits

Brightwaters’ Board of Trustees did not audit 109 payments worth $381,067 before the village paid them, the New York State Comptroller’s Office reported Oct. 23. The finding came from a review of 183 nonpayroll disbursements totaling about $1.3 million. State auditors also questioned the board’s oversight of the treasurer’s financial duties.

The village made 997 nonpayroll payments totaling approximately $3.1 million from its general fund during the period examined. The statewide audit team selected a smaller set for detailed review. Its count of 109 late claims reviews applies to that selected group. The report did not extrapolate the result to every disbursement for the village.

Trustees also lacked a routine independent check on bank reconciliations. The clerk-treasurer handled multiple financial duties and the board did not divide those responsibilities or review the work as a compensating step. A completed reconciliation should explain the difference between the cash shown in the village’s books and the balance reported by the bank. Its value depends on the board receiving reliable, timely support for the figures it is asked to oversee.

The report called out a separate set of documentation problems within the same group of disbursements. For 29 claims worth $72,557, auditors found a voucher, invoice or other supporting record was missing. For 22 claims totaling $81,504, the village lacked required quotes. Three claims worth $9,730 included $783 in improperly paid sales tax.

Those dollar figures describe different tests. The $381,067 represents money disbursed before board review, while $783 is the tax amount improperly included on the three claims. The review’s findings concern oversight of payments, evidence supporting claims and, in the case of the tax, a specific payment error. They do not establish that all the money tied to a procedural problem was improperly spent.

The state audit also distinguishes the board’s signatures from the supporting records. The village’s policy required trustees to sign claims or the abstracts that list them. Auditors found they had not done so as required. A dated approval tied to an individual claim or a particular list makes it easier to establish whether the board performed its review before payment. A later signature may record that members saw the expense without showing that advance review took place.

The distinction matters because a board can approve a budget without ever making a decision about the details of an individual bill. A claims audit gives the board an opportunity to check a vendor’s paperwork, match the payment to municipal business and confirm the village followed its purchasing process before the disbursement goes out. Missing invoices and quotes make that work harder even if a service was delivered.

The comptroller identified nine recommendations covering the claims process and the board’s oversight. The report says village officials agreed and indicated they would take corrective action. The state office included the report in a separate roundup on Nov. 5, after the audit’s October release.

The state report directs the board to prepare a written corrective action plan within 90 days under General Municipal Law § 35. It also encourages the village to make the plan available for public review in the clerk-treasurer’s office. That document would show who is responsible for changing the process and how the board intends to record its decisions. A published agreement with the audit’s recommendations is an initial response. The report does not document completion of the fixes.