Fourth Circuit upheld Fairfax’s revised Thomas Jefferson admissions policy
The court reversed an Alexandria ruling that found the selective public high school's admissions redesign violated equal protection.
The Fourth Circuit reversed an Eastern District of Virginia judgment that had barred Fairfax County’s revised admissions program for Thomas Jefferson High School for Science and Technology. The 2023 decision concerned how a district can change the route into a selective public school while complying with the Equal Protection Clause.
Fairfax removed an entrance test and adopted a process using multiple measures, including grades, written materials and designated experience factors. The redesign also offered a route to admission tied to participating middle schools. The Coalition for TJ argued the changes intentionally disadvantaged Asian American applicants. The board defended the program as serving expanded access and geographic representation.
The appellate majority held that the policy did not have a disparate impact on Asian American applicants on the record before it and that the evidence did not establish discriminatory intent. The dissent argued the evidence supported a different outcome. The Supreme Court denied review in February 2024, leaving the circuit judgment in place without issuing a merits opinion. The case shows how closely an equal-protection analysis can depend on the comparison groups and evidence a court considers.
