Skip to content
Courts

Court sentences Rex Heuermann to life without parole in Gilgo Beach case

The Suffolk County judgment followed guilty pleas to seven murders and a separate admission in open court to an eighth killing.

By Suffolk County Liberty Report Editorial DeskPublished
A drawn courthouse with a classical colonnade.
Contextual image. A drawn courthouse with a classical colonnade. Suffolk County Liberty Report. Image credits

Justice Timothy P. Mazzei sentenced Rex Heuermann in Riverhead on June 17 to three consecutive terms of life imprisonment without the possibility of parole and an additional consecutive term of 100 years to life. The sentence followed guilty pleas in April to three counts of first-degree murder and four counts of second-degree murder. Relatives addressed the court at sentencing, ending the trial-court prosecution of the seven charged killings after an investigation spanning decades.

The first-degree counts concerned Melissa Barthelemy, Amber Costello and Megan Waterman. The additional prison term concerned Maureen Brainard-Barnes, Sandra Costilla, Valerie Mack and Jessica Taylor. Heuermann also admitted in open court to killing Karen Vergata. The Suffolk district attorney said that admission was covered by the plea agreement on the seven charged murders. The distinction explains why the court imposed a sentence on seven counts while acknowledging eight killings.

The Suffolk district attorney convened a new task force in January 2022, according to an Associated Press chronology. The task force included county investigators as well as state and federal personnel. The later prosecutions expanded beyond the cases first charged in July 2023 as authorities developed evidence in other deaths. The sentence addresses the cases specified in the plea. Investigations of other deaths should be understood on their own records.

The sentencing disposition is the latest outcome established by the sources linked below. This account uses the court disposition described by the district attorney and independent reporting from the courtroom, with the charged murders and the additional admission identified separately.