Skip to content
Courts

Holtsville battery storage developer prevails in Suffolk permit dispute

The trial court annulled the county board’s decision and ordered action on the facility’s Article 12 permit or registration.

By Suffolk County Liberty Report Editorial DeskPublished
A drawn courthouse with a classical colonnade.
Contextual image. A drawn courthouse with a classical colonnade. Suffolk County Liberty Report. Image credits

A Suffolk County judge on July 30 annulled a decision by the county Department of Health Services Board of Review concerning a proposed battery energy storage facility in Holtsville. The Article 78 judgment directed the county to issue an Article 12 permit or confirm that registration was complete and otherwise allow construction to commence within 10 days of entry of the order.

The county had required the developer to seek a variance under Article 7 of the Suffolk County Sanitary Code. The litigation examined the factual and legal basis for moving the project from its original Article 12 review into the variance process. After a May 12 trial, the judge concluded that the record lacked facts supporting the switch and rejected the county’s interpretation of a provision referring to a building. The judge identified the relevant equipment as outdoor components rather than storage inside a building.

The order resolved the county health review challenged by the developer. A separate state Department of Public Service docket shows that, by October, the developer and related companies were making filings concerning ownership interests in the project. State energy authorities also listed Holtsville in a September announcement about energy storage awards. Those documents concern different parts of the project’s regulatory and financing history.

The court ordered a specific local administrative step. Its decision and the later state documents cited here do not establish the date construction began, the existence of a completed facility, or a later appellate disposition.