Appeals court affirms Suffolk dismissal of malpractice claim against two defendants
The panel found that the plaintiffs’ expert did not answer the defense experts’ specific opinions on care and causation.
The Second Department on November 4 affirmed dismissal of a Suffolk County medical malpractice claim against a physician and a medical practice. The appeal concerned the evidence submitted for and against summary judgment. The decision addressed the two parties that made the motion and did not purport to resolve the status of the action against every defendant.
The motion relied on two defense experts, who reviewed records, deposition testimony and the pleadings. They concluded that the treatment did not depart from accepted standards and did not proximately cause the claimed injuries. The panel held that this evidence carried the defendants’ initial burden on the arguments they made.
The court then examined the plaintiffs’ expert submission. It found that the submission did not specifically address the relevant defense opinions and relied on assertions that the record did not support. The panel concluded that the plaintiffs had not created a factual dispute requiring a trial on the claim as to those two defendants.
The ruling illustrates how summary judgment operates when specialized evidence is central to a claim. An expert dispute can require a trial when it is grounded in the record and addresses the relevant issue. The panel upheld dismissal after examining the substance of the opinions actually offered in this case.
