Southampton home-staging case can proceed on alleged oral agreement
The court held the complaint adequately alleged a services arrangement and rejected an early attempt to dismiss the contract claim under sales-of-goods rules.
The Second Department on February 25 allowed a breach-of-contract claim over work staging a Southampton property to proceed. The plaintiffs alleged that they had an oral agreement to stage the property in return for one percent of the sale price. They said the owner also agreed to pay for furnishings if the buyer chose to keep them.
According to the complaint as summarized by the court, the property sold in February 2022 and the buyer elected to purchase the furnishings. The plaintiffs alleged that they were paid neither the design fee nor the additional amount for the furnishings. The defendants argued that the alleged agreement was unenforceable under the writing requirement in Uniform Commercial Code section 2-201.
The panel explained that Article 2 applies to transactions predominantly for the sale of goods. An agreement can include items of personal property and still be mainly for services. With the allegations read in the plaintiffs’ favor at the motion-to-dismiss stage, the court held that the complaint adequately described staging as the predominant service. It affirmed the denial of the branch of the motion aimed at dismissing the breach claim.
The ruling keeps that claim in litigation. It does not establish what the parties actually agreed to, whether they performed, or how much money is due. The distinction between a pleading and proof matters in a dispute built around disputed oral terms.
