Suffolk medical business dispute illustrates limits on immediate appeals
The Second Department dismissed an appeal addressing a conversion claim that the trial judge had dismissed on the court’s own initiative.
The Second Department dismissed an appeal on January 21 in a dispute involving Nassau-Suffolk Medical Services, P.C. The plaintiff had sued both individually and on behalf of the company, asserting a derivative conversion claim alongside other claims. During the case, the plaintiff moved for leave to serve a third amended complaint. The Suffolk County judge directed dismissal of the conversion claim on the court’s own initiative.
The appeals court held that the portion of the order issued on the court’s own initiative was not appealable as of right in the circumstances. It declined to treat the notice of appeal as an application for leave to appeal. The panel also explained that a party cannot obtain review merely because language or reasoning in an order is viewed as adverse.
The order concerns appellate procedure. It does not decide whether the underlying conversion allegations were substantiated or adjudicate the separate contract and fiduciary claims. The issue was whether the particular portions of the trial court’s order were properly before the appellate court at that stage.
The case highlights an often consequential question in civil practice. A litigant may object to what a trial court wrote without having a right to immediate appellate review of that language or of a ruling issued without a motion made on notice. The opinion identifies the procedural limits applied to this record.
