Ronkonkoma station sidewalk suit can proceed against the Long Island Rail Road
The Second Department found that the railroad’s ownership and maintenance evidence was inconclusive. The county, town and MTA remained out of the case.
A state appeals court on January 14 reinstated a claim against the Long Island Rail Road over an alleged sidewalk defect at or near its Ronkonkoma station. The trial court had dismissed the claim against the railroad, Metropolitan Transportation Authority, Suffolk County and Town of Islip following discovery. The Second Department changed the result only for the railroad.
The rail defendants’ submissions did not clearly identify the boundaries of the railroad’s property or establish who maintained the particular stretch of sidewalk. As a result, the judges found the railroad had not met its initial burden to secure judgment without trial. They separately held that the MTA could not be held vicariously liable for a subsidiary’s tort on the theory presented.
The county and town supported their motions with evidence that they had not received prior written notice of the alleged defect as required by their local laws. The court did not find a triable dispute as to the exceptions raised concerning special use or affirmative creation of the condition. Those rulings left dismissal in place for both municipal defendants.
The reinstatement does not establish that the railroad owned the sidewalk or caused the alleged injury. It leaves the claim open for further litigation. The opinion shows why a single location can produce different results for the railroad, an authority and the local governments when their legal duties and evidence differ.
