Skip to content
Courts

Appellate judges reinstate Suffolk robbery indictment in Symns case

The court held that the grand jury record could support an inference of shared intent and returned the case to Suffolk County Court.

By Suffolk County Liberty Report Editorial DeskPublished
A drawn courthouse with a classical colonnade.
Contextual image. A drawn courthouse with a classical colonnade. Suffolk County Liberty Report. Image credits

The Appellate Division reinstated a Suffolk County robbery indictment against Kelechi Symns on May 27, reversing a March 2025 County Court order that had dismissed the charges for insufficient grand jury evidence. The case was returned to Suffolk County Court for proceedings on two first-degree and one second-degree robbery counts.

The appellate court reviewed allegations that Symns knew of a plan to rob a person he knew and assisted the other people charged in connection with the incident. The decision discussed conduct before, during and after the alleged robbery. The panel concluded that the evidence, viewed under the grand jury standard, could support a finding that Symns intentionally aided the offense and shared the required intent.

New York’s accessorial liability statute requires the mental culpability for the underlying offense and intentional aid or another specified form of participation. The panel explained that merely being present or knowing people involved does not satisfy the rule. For a grand jury challenge, the reviewing court considers whether the evidence could support the elements if proven. A jury at trial would have to apply the separate standard of proof beyond a reasonable doubt.

The appellate decision restores charges. It does not determine whether Symns committed the offenses, and he is presumed innocent unless proven guilty. The public opinion records the remand and does not include a later trial disposition.