Skip to content
Courts

Appeals court leaves Suffolk construction default judgment vacated

A panel upheld the reopening of a construction dispute after concluding that the contractor lacked actual notice of a court conference.

By Suffolk County Liberty Report Editorial DeskPublished
A drawn courthouse with a classical colonnade.
Contextual image. A drawn courthouse with a classical colonnade. Suffolk County Liberty Report. Image credits

The Second Department on September 16 upheld an order vacating a default judgment in a Suffolk County construction contract dispute. Contractor Santorelli Builders had missed a January 2025 court conference. Its absence led to dismissal of the claims against 146 Norris Realty and a judgment of $199,420.92 on that defendant’s counterclaims. The appellate decision leaves in place a later order that reopened that part of the case.

The judges focused on whether the contractor received actual notice. The company principal denied receiving the earlier order and said he did not know about the conference. The court found that the only notice went by regular mail to his home address without showing that the company addressee was in his care. That discrepancy gave the denial of receipt support in the record. The opinion does not turn every denial of a mailed notice into a requirement to reopen a case.

The panel explained that the absence of actual notice can mean there was no default in the first place. It added that even if there had been a default, it was a single missed appearance early in the case, with a brief delay before the request to reopen and no demonstrated prejudice. The order also left the contractor’s notice of pendency in place.

The ruling concerns the validity of the default judgment. The construction claims and counterclaims were not decided on their underlying evidence in this appeal.