Skip to content
Courts

Southampton Village wetlands amendment faces preliminary injunction

A Suffolk judge temporarily blocked enforcement of the 2025 amendment and declined at that stage to enjoin the entire subdivision review.

By Suffolk County Liberty Report Editorial DeskPublished
A drawn courthouse with a classical colonnade.
Contextual image. A drawn courthouse with a classical colonnade. Suffolk County Liberty Report. Image credits

A Suffolk County judge temporarily barred Southampton Village from enforcing Local Law No. 9 of 2025 in a February 17 decision. A neighboring landowner brought the challenge in connection with a proposed subdivision on Wickapogue Road. The local law removed issuance of wetlands permits from the village list of actions designated Type I under the State Environmental Quality Review Act.

The neighbor sought both an injunction against the law and a broader halt to processing the subdivision. The developer disputed that the subdivision needed a wetlands permit under either version of the law. The court treated the request to block action on the subdivision as premature given the procedural status before it. It separately granted temporary relief against use of the amendment, citing its preliminary view of the challenge and the equities involved in retaining the longstanding rules while the case was heard.

The order did not finally annul the law or resolve the project’s environmental classification. Requests concerning an earlier negative declaration, village resolutions and an alleged Open Meetings Law violation were left for further proceedings. The court adjourned the remaining demands and motions to dismiss for oral argument.

The ruling distinguishes the local procedural rule from permission for a particular project. A preliminary injunction temporarily restricts what the village can do within the terms of the order. It does not establish that the subdivision was ultimately prohibited, approved or built. The public records reviewed for this account do not establish a later final merits judgment.