Skip to content
Federal Docket · EDVA

Verizon kept part of its Vonage patent win as appeals court vacated the damages award

The Federal Circuit upheld infringement findings on two patents and set aside the result on a third in a Virginia telecommunications case.

By Suffolk County Liberty Report Editorial DeskPublished
Albert V. Bryan United States Courthouse in Alexandria, Virginia.
Contextual image. Albert V. Bryan United States Courthouse in Alexandria, Virginia. dctim1. Image credits

In 2007 the Federal Circuit reviewed a verdict won by Verizon against Vonage in the Eastern District of Virginia. The jury found infringement of asserted claims from three patents. The district court’s judgment included $58 million in compensatory damages and a prospective royalty, along with an injunction.

The appeals court upheld infringement findings on two patents after agreeing with how the trial court interpreted their disputed terms. It concluded the district court misread a disputed term in the third patent and set that part of the ruling aside for a new trial. The panel preserved the injunction as to the remaining two patents and vacated the entire $58 million damages award and the 5.5 percent royalty.

Vonage and Verizon signed a settlement on October 25. Vonage disclosed in its annual report that the denial of rehearing triggered a $120 million settlement payment, which it made in the fourth quarter of 2007. That payment arose from the parties’ agreement after the appellate ruling.