Skip to content
Courts

Second Department finds owner and contractor liable on steel-hoisting claim

The appellate panel granted summary judgment on one Labor Law claim following an ironworker’s injury. It left other requested liability rulings in place.

By Suffolk County Liberty Report Editorial DeskPublished
A drawn courthouse with a classical colonnade.
Contextual image. A drawn courthouse with a classical colonnade. Suffolk County Liberty Report. Image credits

The Second Department on August 19 held that a construction-site owner and general contractor were liable under a New York Labor Law provision in a Suffolk County case arising from an ironworker’s injury. The court granted the worker summary judgment on liability under section 240(1) as against OLP Hauppauge and LMJ Management & Construction. It left the other challenged denials of summary judgment intact.

The record included testimony by the worker and a crane operator about a steel beam that swung while it was being hoisted. The judges found that the beam needed to be secured for the job and that the injury flowed directly from the force of gravity on it. The owner and contractor did not offer evidence that created a triable issue on the motion addressing that particular statutory claim.

The appeal also involved a request for summary judgment under a different Labor Law provision and an ordinary negligence claim against the crane company. The worker did not obtain those liability rulings. Those claims involved separate legal theories and parties.

The ruling establishes liability on the specified section 240(1) claim. The opinion does not set a damages award. It offers a local example of how an elevated load can lead to liability under the statute even where the injured worker’s account centers on a swinging object rather than a fall by the worker.