Bay Shore home insurance dispute turns on number of dwelling units
Suffolk’s appeals court sent the case back for a declaration that the homeowner policies were void from the outset.
An appeals court on October 7 upheld a ruling in favor of Otsego Mutual Fire Insurance Company in a coverage dispute over a house in Bay Shore. The Second Department returned the case to Suffolk County Supreme Court for entry of a judgment declaring the policies void from the start. The dispute reached court after the insurer declined a claim for damage from a broken pipe.
The insurance application completed through the homeowner’s broker represented that the property was a one-family dwelling. In investigating the claim, the insurer identified three units with separate facilities and access. The issue the court addressed was whether the application materially misrepresented the risk the insurer was asked to cover.
The panel found that the insurer supported its motion with an underwriting official’s affidavit and downstate underwriting guidelines. Those materials showed it would not have issued the policies for a three-family dwelling. The court found no opposing evidence sufficient to create a triable issue under the standard it applied.
This was a civil ruling about eligibility for the policies based on the application and underwriting record. It was not a criminal fraud judgment or a ruling that every discrepancy in an insurance application warrants rescission. The materiality finding depended on whether this insurer would have issued the policy on the accurate facts.
