Skip to content
Courts

Second Department reverses foreclosure judgment on Babylon property

The bank did not meet its summary-judgment burden on standing and proof of the required 90-day mailings.

By Suffolk County Liberty Report Editorial DeskPublished
A drawn courthouse with a classical colonnade.
Contextual image. A drawn courthouse with a classical colonnade. Suffolk County Liberty Report. Image credits

A state appeals court on October 21 reversed a judgment directing the foreclosure sale of a home in Babylon. Bank of America had obtained a 2025 Suffolk County judgment. The Second Department denied the bank summary judgment as against the estate at issue and restored affirmative defenses concerning standing and the required 90-day pre-foreclosure notice.

The court said a woman who executed the mortgage as a borrower and agreed in the mortgage to pay amounts due was entitled to notice under Real Property Actions and Proceedings Law section 1304. She had not signed the note. The panel looked at the commitments made in the mortgage when deciding whether the notice requirement applied to her.

Section 1304 required evidence of delivery by qualifying mail methods. The bank produced evidence of certified mailing, but its submissions did not establish actual first-class mailing or explain sufficiently a standard office procedure designed to ensure it. The panel also found the bank’s submission insufficient to show standing on the motion.

The reversal sets aside the order directing the sale under that judgment. It does not give the estate judgment dismissing the foreclosure action. A separate objection under section 1306 about reporting borrower information did not produce dismissal. The opinion illustrates how notice, standing and the merits of an underlying debt can produce different rulings within one case.