Belle Terre’s zoning case reached the Supreme Court over who could live together
A Suffolk village’s definition of family was upheld in 1974. A later decision drew a distinction for ordinances that divided extended families.
In 1974, the U.S. Supreme Court upheld a Belle Terre, Suffolk County, zoning ordinance that restricted who could live together in a one-family dwelling. The village’s definition permitted related households and groups of up to two unrelated people. Six college students who shared a house, and the owners who rented the house to them, challenged the rule.
The majority saw the definition as an ordinary land-use regulation with a rational relationship to permissible local aims, including low density, limited traffic and a quiet residential character. It upheld the ordinance as applied to the unrelated household before the Court and reversed a federal appellate judgment. Justice Thurgood Marshall dissented, arguing that the chosen living arrangement implicated constitutionally protected interests and that the village could pursue its goals with less restrictive tools.
Three years later, the Supreme Court struck down a different occupancy ordinance in Moore v City of East Cleveland. That case involved a grandmother and grandsons who were relatives but whose household did not fit the city’s narrower permitted groupings. The Supreme Court’s plurality distinguished Belle Terre as a rule affecting unrelated people and emphasized constitutional protection of extended family living arrangements.
Reading the decisions together clarifies their scope. Belle Terre concerned the relationship between local zoning and a household made up of unrelated residents. Moore addressed local regulation that broke up an extended family household. The cases present different constitutional questions even though each began with a municipality defining who could occupy a home.
These historical opinions explain why a village on the North Shore became a reference point in land-use cases nationwide. They describe the ordinances and legal disputes before the Court when decided. Current local housing rules and the effect of later statutes must be checked separately.

