Skip to content
Federal Docket · EDVA

How standing ended Virginia’s own Richmond challenge to the Affordable Care Act

The Fourth Circuit directed dismissal because Virginia had not shown the injury necessary to bring its particular challenge.

By Suffolk County Liberty Report Editorial DeskPublished
Albert V. Bryan United States Courthouse in Alexandria, Virginia.
Contextual image. Albert V. Bryan United States Courthouse in Alexandria, Virginia. dctim1. Image credits

Virginia challenged a provision of the Affordable Care Act in federal court in Richmond, arguing that the federal individual mandate conflicted with a state enactment concerning health coverage. The district court accepted the Commonwealth’s standing and held the federal provision unconstitutional. The Fourth Circuit took a different view of the threshold issue.

The appeals court concluded in September 2011 that the asserted conflict did not give Virginia standing. It reasoned that a state could not manufacture an injury sufficient for federal jurisdiction simply by enacting a declaration objecting to a federal requirement directed at individuals. It vacated the district court judgment and returned the case with instructions to dismiss.

The ruling addressed which plaintiff could present which claim in that case. It did not settle the constitutional validity of the Affordable Care Act for other litigants or later cases. That is why a docket entry saying that a judgment was vacated deserves a look at the reason for the disposition.