Suffolk jail case drew a line around local power to make civil immigration arrests
The court held that New York law did not authorize ordinary state and local officers to arrest someone on civil immigration grounds.
New York’s Appellate Division ruled in 2018 that state and local officers lacked authority under New York law to make civil immigration arrests. The case arose after the Suffolk County sheriff continued to hold a person at the Riverhead correctional facility after the sentence on a state charge had been completed. The sheriff relied on a federal immigration detainer and an administrative arrest warrant.
The court identified the additional detention as an arrest separate from the one that brought the person into state custody. It distinguished the administrative papers issued by federal immigration authorities from criminal warrants issued by a court under New York law. The authorities the sheriff cited did not supply state-law authority to continue the custody for a suspected civil immigration violation.
The panel said it was deciding the power of state and local officers under New York law. It did not decide the federal officers’ authority to act under federal immigration law. The decision’s historical scope is also important in evaluating later arrangements with federal agencies. A later case involving different statutory authority, agreements or facts requires its own analysis.
The Riverhead case illustrates why the legal basis for each period of detention matters. Someone may have been held lawfully at the outset and still challenge the authority for detention after the original basis ends. The state court opinion explains that distinction in the specific context of a Suffolk County jail.
