Gloucester school restroom policy violated Title IX and equal protection, appeals court held
The 2020 Grimm decision affirmed a judgment from the Eastern District of Virginia concerning a transgender student’s treatment by a public school board.
The Fourth Circuit affirmed a district court judgment for Gavin Grimm, a former Gloucester County public school student who challenged a board policy restricting his access to the boys’ restrooms. The opinion also addressed the board’s refusal to update his school records. The litigation began in the Eastern District of Virginia.
The school board defended its restroom policy in part by invoking student privacy. The panel majority examined how the policy operated for Grimm and held that it violated both Title IX and the Equal Protection Clause. The opinion addressed the record developed in that dispute, including the use of single-stall alternatives and the practical consequences of requiring Grimm to use different facilities.
The panel found differential treatment and assessed the evidence supporting the board’s justifications. A dissent took a different view of the statutory question. In June 2021 the Supreme Court declined to hear the school board’s appeal, leaving the Fourth Circuit judgment in place.
