How a federal consent decree changed voting for the Islip Town Council
Latino voters challenged townwide council elections under the federal Voting Rights Act. The approved agreement required four council districts.
On October 14, 2020, a federal court approved a consent decree ending the use of townwide elections for the four seats on the Islip Town Council. Latino voters and a voting-rights organization had challenged the at-large system in 2018, saying it diluted their opportunity to elect representatives of their choice under Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act.
Before the agreement, the court had denied a request for a preliminary injunction. That ruling concerned whether to change the election system while the case was unresolved. The election dispute remained pending and the parties ultimately entered a consent judgment before trial. In it, the town and town board stipulated that the at-large system for council elections violated Section 2 and agreed to a permanent injunction against its use beginning with the regular 2021 election.
The agreement called for four council districts and required District 1 to have a majority of Hispanic or Latino citizens of voting age. It also provided for $900,000 in fees, costs and expenses. Those are terms of the consent decree. The order was achieved through agreement and did not follow a completed trial on the federal claim.
The local significance lies in who votes for a particular council seat. In the former system, voters across Islip voted for those seats. Under the decree, the council districts are distinct constituencies. The order concerns Town Council elections, not every elected position or every subsequent map question in town.
