Milla appeal revived a Fairfax police-stop suit and left a notice question open
The Fourth Circuit vacated judgment for two Fairfax officers. It reserved whether the district’s practice satisfied the Roseboro notice requirement.
In Milla v. Brown, the Fourth Circuit vacated summary judgment for two Fairfax officers. Viewed in the light most favorable to Anthry Milla, the evidence supported a conclusion that officers lacked particularized suspicion to stop and seize him. The court also vacated the qualified-immunity ruling and returned the case for further proceedings.
The opinion discussed the warning associated with Roseboro v. Garrison. A self-represented party facing summary judgment must receive an understandable explanation of the right to respond with evidence and the possible consequences of failing to respond. The officers’ lawyers supplied the warning required by an Eastern District of Virginia local rule, and Milla argued the district court itself should have issued it.
Milla had not raised the issue in the district court or in his informal opening brief on appeal. The panel treated that issue as forfeited, declined to undertake fundamental-error review, and reserved whether the local rule complies with Roseboro. The reasonable-suspicion analysis supplied the basis for the vacatur.
