Skip to content
Courts

Suffolk loan judgment stands after appeal over missing original agreement

An appeals court found that the trial judge could admit a reliable copy of a disputed agreement after hearing an explanation for the missing original.

By Suffolk County Liberty Report Editorial DeskPublished
A drawn courthouse with a classical colonnade.
Contextual image. A drawn courthouse with a classical colonnade. Suffolk County Liberty Report. Image credits

The Second Department on March 25 affirmed a Suffolk County judgment concerning a disputed personal loan. After a bench trial, the trial judge awarded the plaintiff $105,841.07 on the cause of action alleging breach of the loan agreement. A central appellate issue was whether the judge properly admitted a copy of the agreement without the original.

The plaintiff testified that he lent the defendant $27,000 in cash and that the defendant took the signed original and later supplied a copy. A witness testified that she observed both parties sign the original and that the copy was accurate. The defendant denied the loan and contested the authenticity of his signature. The appeals panel relied on the trial judge’s assessment of the witnesses when reviewing that conflicting testimony.

The best evidence rule ordinarily calls for an original when the contents of a writing are disputed. The Second Department explained that a court can admit secondary evidence when the proponent sufficiently accounts for the original’s absence and shows the substitute accurately reflects it. The panel found that the trial judge acted within his discretion in making those findings here.

The amount originally loaned was part of the testimony. The larger amount stated by the court is the total judgment on that cause of action. The appellate ruling upheld the judgment and did not state whether it had been collected.