Federal judge dismisses Suffolk County’s challenge to even-year elections
A June decision ended the claims of the local-government plaintiffs. Private plaintiffs later filed an amended First Amendment challenge.
U.S. District Judge Gary R. Brown dismissed the federal complaint challenging New York’s Even Year Election Law on June 29. Suffolk County and the Town of Huntington were among the remaining governmental plaintiffs and had their claims dismissed with prejudice. The judge denied the preliminary injunction request as moot and allowed the nonmunicipal plaintiffs to pursue a different pleading against individual election commissioners.
The ruling identified multiple reasons why the government plaintiffs could not pursue the federal claims. The decision discussed the effect of the earlier state litigation, standing under Article III and whether the government plaintiffs could invoke the federal civil rights cause of action. The case followed an October 2025 New York Court of Appeals decision upholding the law against the challenge presented there. The federal ruling left the election calendar in effect.
Local and statewide Republican organizations and other nonmunicipal plaintiffs took a different procedural path. Their lawyers announced that they filed a second amended complaint on July 9 raising a First Amendment theory against individual commissioners of the State Board of Elections. That filing keeps the later private plaintiffs’ claims distinct from those that Suffolk County and Huntington lost. No final merits ruling on the amended First Amendment claim is established by the sources used here.
The 2023 law moved a number of county and town offices to even-numbered election years, and its application varies by position. The State Board of Elections lists exceptions, including several offices with terms fixed in the New York Constitution. Readers comparing local races should distinguish the schedule in state guidance from the issues raised in pending federal pleadings.
