Skip to content
Investigations

Asharoken audit finds missing records for village bills

The state found $69,707 in payments with improper claim reviews. Auditors said the 232 selected payments served valid village purposes.

By Suffolk County Liberty Report Editorial DeskPublished
H. Lee Dennison County Executive Building in Hauppauge, New York.
Contextual image. H. Lee Dennison County Executive Building in Hauppauge, New York. Americasroof, perspective correction by Filetime. Image credits

State auditors found that Asharoken’s trustees did not properly audit 51 nonpayroll payments worth $69,707. The March 6 report examined village claims and oversight of the treasurer between June 2023 and December 2024. The auditors said the 232 payments they selected, worth $877,625, were for valid village purposes.

The problems were in the way different payments were documented or approved. Some claim files lacked invoices or vouchers. Others lacked signatures, included late charges or were missing from the lists trustees received. A claim file is supposed to let a reviewer reconstruct what was purchased, what the vendor charged and who approved the bill.

The claim lists presented a related problem. The auditors examined all 19 lists, covering $2.34 million. Eighteen did not supply check numbers and dates. The board adopted a resolution for each list and included a dollar amount each time, but auditors found that 14 resolutions omitted the range of check numbers. A total alone gives a reader little help in linking an individual payment to a particular board action.

The audit also found that trustees did not regularly check bank reconciliations required by village policy or review bank transfers made by the treasurer. A bank reconciliation helps detect when the balance in the village’s books differs from the bank’s. An independent review is useful when one office performs several steps in the payment and accounting process.

Auditors said Asharoken had some controls in place. They raised concerns with officials in August 2024 and documented subsequent changes to claims, payments and administration. When they looked again, they found continuing problems, including missing invoices, late charges and unreconciled oversight. The final report contains eight recommendations.

Village officials disputed parts of the findings and said they intended to take corrective action. The published report includes the village’s response and the state office’s comments. The response matters because the parties agree that changes are warranted while disagreeing on aspects of how the auditors described the earlier practices.