Skip to content
Government

East Hampton Village patio variance denial survives court review

The zoning board approved a shed and denied separate setback relief for a patio. A judge found grounds to uphold the patio decision.

By Suffolk County Liberty Report Editorial DeskPublished
Montauk Point Lighthouse in Suffolk County, New York.
Contextual image. Montauk Point Lighthouse in Suffolk County, New York. Kevin Pepin. Image credits

Suffolk County Supreme Court upheld the East Hampton Village Zoning Board of Appeals’ refusal to grant setback relief for a proposed patio. The Jan. 14, 2025 decision denied the owner’s Article 78 petition in a case brought by 25 Cross Hwy. LLC.

The proposed patio would sit 18 feet from one front yard lot line and 12 feet from another, where the village code required 35 feet, the decision said. The owner sought a variance for the patio and relief allowing an existing shed to remain. After public hearings, the board approved the request for the shed and denied the patio request.

New York’s area-variance framework directs boards to consider the benefit sought by an applicant against possible harm to the neighborhood. The factors include the size of the requested departure, potential environmental and neighborhood effects, whether another practical solution is available and whether the difficulty was self-created. Boards may give those considerations different weight on different applications.

The judge reviewed whether the board acted within its lawful discretion and had a rational basis for its determination. Under that standard, the court does not hold a new variance hearing or choose between different patio designs. Its assessment is whether the administrative decision can stand on the record.

The ruling leaves the patio decision in place for the proposal the board considered. The board’s approval for the shed was a separate part of the same application. The case illustrates why relief on one part of a property plan does not determine whether a different part satisfies the variance standard.