Skip to content
Investigations

Eastport fire district lacked competition for $214,672 in professional and insurance services

State auditors also found the district paid $96,955 to vendors without obtaining quotes required by its own policy.

By Suffolk County Liberty Report Editorial DeskPublished
H. Lee Dennison County Executive Building in Hauppauge, New York.
Contextual image. H. Lee Dennison County Executive Building in Hauppauge, New York. Americasroof, perspective correction by Filetime. Image credits

The Eastport Fire District bought $214,672 in professional and insurance services without using a competitive method, New York’s comptroller reported Sept. 5, 2025. Auditors separately found that the district paid $96,955 to 20 vendors without obtaining quotes required by its local purchasing policy.

The audit traced both types of purchases to shortcomings in the district’s process. The local policy addressed purchases that did not require formal bidding, but provided no guidance or encouragement for seeking competition in procuring professional services or insurance. For the 20 vendors, a quote requirement already existed and the comptroller found officials did not follow it.

The categories covered a portion of the district’s purchases. State auditors said Eastport paid 108 vendors about $847,191 in total during the period. The professional services and insurance involved 11 vendors. The audit’s figures describe purchases examined under different checks and do not measure a price premium.

Formal bidding, written proposals and requests for quotes are different approaches to documenting a competitive purchase. For services involving specialized qualifications, a request for proposals can allow an organization to compare relevant experience and terms alongside price. The comptroller said Eastport lacked assurance it had obtained the most economical terms when it went without competition.

The state report made three recommendations and says district officials generally agreed. Its appendices include the district’s response and the auditors’ methodology. The comptroller says the board must send a written corrective action plan within 90 days and encourages it to make the plan available for public review. That plan and later purchasing files would show how the district put any policy revisions into practice.