West Hampton Dunes subdivision variance denial upheld
Suffolk Supreme Court rejected a challenge to the village zoning board’s refusal to grant nine area variances for a proposed split.
A Suffolk County Supreme Court judge upheld West Hampton Dunes’ denial of nine zoning variances sought to divide a residential property. The March 3, 2025 ruling dismissed the owner’s Article 78 challenge to the zoning board’s June 2024 decision.
The property is in the village’s R-40 residential district. The new application sought relief from requirements including minimum lot area, lot width and side yards. Among the listed requests were a reduction from the 40,000-square-foot minimum to 15,100 square feet and a lot width of 56 feet where 150 was required. The zoning board denied the application by a vote of four to zero.
The owner had secured a divided board’s approval for similar relief in 2006, under an earlier design. The court described the earlier proposed acreage and the planned dedication of open space. It also set out the details of the later application. Those details mattered because a board can explain a change in outcome by pointing to material differences between prior and current proposals or circumstances.
Under Village Law, an area variance is evaluated by balancing the owner’s benefit against concerns including neighborhood character, the extent of the deviations, practical alternatives and environmental impacts. The court reviewed the board’s decision under the deferential standard applicable to zoning determinations and found grounds to let it stand.
The decision leaves in place the denial of the nine variances required by the 2024 proposal. It concerns the particular subdivision and application record before the court, including the earlier approval the owner cited.

