Skip to content
Government

East Hampton Village inn can continue challenge over proposed pool

A Suffolk judge dismissed some claims but ordered the village to answer those that survived. The court did not grant a variance.

By Suffolk County Liberty Report Editorial DeskPublished
Montauk Point Lighthouse in Suffolk County, New York.
Contextual image. Montauk Point Lighthouse in Suffolk County, New York. Kevin Pepin. Image credits

A Suffolk County judge allowed parts of the Huntting Inn’s challenge to East Hampton Village’s handling of a proposed swimming pool to continue. The April 10 decision directed the village defendants to respond to the remaining claims and dismissed constitutional takings claims. It did not order construction or approve the pool.

The inn includes guest rooms and a restaurant in a residential district. The decision describes it as a commercial use that predates the restrictions applicable to the district. Its owner, Huntting Hospitality, sought variances relating to a pool. The Zoning Board of Appeals concluded that the code barred it from granting those variances because the pool would introduce an outdoor use to a preexisting commercial use.

The owner challenged the treatment of the application. The ruling discusses the code’s treatment of new outdoor uses and how the zoning board interpreted it in relation to other applications. At the pleading stage, the judge evaluated whether claims had a sufficient legal and factual basis to continue. Those allegations remained to be tested through later proceedings.

Among the surviving claims was one alleging unequal treatment. The owner pointed to the village board’s handling of an application associated with the Hedges Inn, another inn in East Hampton. The court found the comparison sufficiently pleaded to allow the claim to go forward. The ruling identifies the parties’ alleged differences in treatment as an issue for a later merits determination.

For the federal due process theories tied to entitlement to a variance, the judge examined how much discretion the zoning board had. The opinion explains that even if the challenged restriction were invalid, the board would retain discretion over the request. That discretion defeated the asserted basis for a protected entitlement to the variance itself. The court also dismissed the takings theories.

The case had briefly moved to federal court after the defendants removed it in December 2024. A stipulation returned it to state court in January 2025 and withdrew a claim under federal civil rights statute § 1983 without prejudice. The April 2026 decision addresses the portions of the amended case that remained before Suffolk Supreme Court.

The question of relief was also before the court. A judge reviewing a zoning decision can in some circumstances return a matter to a board for a merits decision. A direction to issue a variance requires an adequate record and a basis for that remedy. The court said a decision about what relief the owner might receive was premature while the surviving claims remained undecided.

The decision directed the defendants to file an answer to the remaining portions of the case after service of the order with notice of entry. The court’s April ruling left the zoning dispute alive and limited the issues it would hear. It did not establish an entitlement to a pool on this property.