Southold ordered to grant coastal permit for Long Island Sound house project
Suffolk Supreme Court found that the town applied the wrong standards when it upheld denial of a permit for a home expansion.
Suffolk County Supreme Court directed Southold to grant a coastal erosion hazard permit for a proposed expansion of a home facing Long Island Sound. On May 27, the court granted the property owners’ Article 78 petition challenging Southold’s administrative denial.
The owners proposed adding an upper story to their existing house. The town Zoning Board of Appeals granted relief in October 2023 from height and lot-coverage requirements. The Town Board of Trustees subsequently denied separate coastal erosion and wetlands permits. The court’s May decision notes that it had annulled the wetlands denial in a separate August 2025 order.
The owners pursued an administrative appeal of the coastal denial to the Town Board, sitting as the Coastal Erosion Hazard Board of Review. It upheld the result in July 2024. The court reviewed that decision as an administrative determination, rather than treating it as a legislative rezoning.
A central issue was the definition of a major addition under the town’s coastal law. The code uses a 25 percent footprint threshold. A separate provision allows a nonmajor addition to an existing structure on a primary dune with an erosion management permit and conditions concerning location, design and impacts. The court read those provisions together and applied them to the plan rather than treating the existence of a third story as decisive.
The judge looked at how the town’s coastal rules applied to the footprint of the project. The plan added 115 square feet to the 1,249-square-foot existing footprint, a 9.2 percent increase, according to the decision. The court said that was below the 25 percent threshold it discussed. The applicable approval also allows reasonable conditions related to the proposed use.
The judge treated the meaning of the local code as a legal question that the court could review independently. The town’s administrative findings also had to explain how its stated reasons applied to this property’s plans. The decision concluded that the board’s reasoning repeated mistakes from the trustees’ original review.
The court separately addressed the responsibilities of the bodies involved. The zoning board, which draws its authority from state law, had approved height and coverage relief. The coastal body could evaluate effects on the dune and impose appropriate permit conditions. The judge held that the coastal review could not function as a second decision on the already-authorized third story.
The court concluded that the town board had failed to correct legal errors by the trustees. It also rejected using the coastal review to nullify the lawful height variance issued by the zoning board. Those conclusions turned on the duties assigned to each town body and the record before them.
The May order directs the town to issue the coastal permit, subject to the decision’s treatment of reasonable conditions. It addresses this project and does not rewrite other coastal restrictions or decide whether an unrelated waterfront proposal qualifies.

