Appeals court permits private judicial review of Suffolk police complaint files
The ruling concerns what a judge may examine in a civil lawsuit, a different procedure from ordering public release.
A state appeals court upheld a Suffolk judge’s direction to examine civilian complaint files in a civil damages case against the county and a police officer. The April 2, 2025 decision permits the judge to inspect the records privately before deciding what, if anything, must be disclosed in the lawsuit.
The plaintiff sued in 2015 alleging an unlawful arrest and assault. In May 2023 he sought civilian complaints involving the officer named as a defendant. Suffolk County Supreme Court ordered an in camera review in August 2023 and amended its direction the following month to require the County Attorney’s Office to provide the records for that review.
The defendants challenged the orders. The appellate panel held that the trial judge could examine the records, including those created before the June 2020 repeal of Civil Rights Law § 50-a. It also applied the principle that unsubstantiated allegations do not give police complaint files automatic protection from disclosure as a category.
The proceeding differs from the county’s public records cases. The plaintiff sought material in discovery, and the orders referred the files to a judge. Private judicial inspection lets the court assess what the records contain and decide which material is relevant or subject to lawful withholding. An in camera order does not place all complaints on the public docket.
The ruling addresses the scope of a discovery step. It does not determine whether the plaintiff’s allegations about the arrest were true or whether complaints in the files had merit. The privacy and relevance questions that remained before the trial judge have to be read in light of the litigation posture described in the appellate decision.
