Court upholds Suffolk’s response timetable for a high-volume records request
The Second Department weighed the amount of requested material and the need to review records that were kept on paper.
The Second Department rejected a bid to compel immediate production of Suffolk County records in a September 2025 ruling. In Waldman v. Suffolk County, the court upheld the dismissal of the portions of the case seeking immediate disclosure and attorneys’ fees. The county had set a date to produce responsive documents and said its timetable reflected the volume of the request and the format in which it kept the files.
The requester brought an Article 78 proceeding in April 2023. Suffolk said it had not denied access and asserted that many documents requiring review existed only on paper. Suffolk County Supreme Court denied the requested relief in October 2023. The appeal tested whether the county’s response was sufficient in the circumstances.
Under Public Officers Law § 89, an agency that grants a request in whole or in part but cannot provide access within 20 business days of its acknowledgment must explain why in writing and give a reasonable date certain. The law’s deadline for the initial response is a related requirement. It does not make immediate production practicable for every request.
The decision turned on the response in this case. Record volume and format can influence a timetable, and an agency must still give the requester an explanation and a concrete date in the circumstances covered by the law. The opinion did not give Suffolk an indefinite extension for other requests.
The panel also held that the requester did not substantially prevail for purposes of the fee statute. The decision focused on the timing and fees claims on appeal. It does not state that every responsive record had been delivered by the date of the ruling.

