Shoreham-Wading River school district loses standing challenge over battery project tax deal
Suffolk Supreme Court dismissed the challenge to Brookhaven’s payment methodology before reaching the merits.
A Suffolk judge dismissed a challenge brought by the Shoreham-Wading River Central School District and others to the calculation of payments in lieu of taxes for a proposed Brookhaven battery storage project. On Dec. 2, 2025, the court held that the challengers lacked standing. It did not decide whether the calculation was sound.
Brookhaven’s industrial development agency approved assistance for a battery energy storage project in February 2025. The approved structure included a sales and use tax exemption and a real-property tax abatement paired with payments in lieu of taxes. The decision describes payments for a 20-year period, after which the facility would be taxed at its then-assessed full value.
The school district did not dispute the agency’s power to provide that type of financial assistance. It challenged the method used to set the amount owed. The district argued that a higher payment would produce more school revenue and could reduce the amount school taxpayers otherwise had to fund.
The agency used a policy it adopted in June 2022 to determine fixed payments for this type of energy storage development. The court’s account says the agency developed the policy after consultation involving the state energy research authority and industry participants. In February 2025 the agency attached a cost-benefit analysis to the resolution approving financial assistance for the project.
The court separated that financial argument from the legal requirement to show a qualifying injury. It concluded that the district’s claimed effects did not give it standing to challenge the amount. It distinguished authorities addressing how the authorized payments are distributed among affected taxing jurisdictions. A residential taxpayer who joined the action also failed to establish a distinct injury, the court held.
New York’s industrial development law requires the payments in this case to be shared in the proportions applicable to the affected taxing jurisdictions. The judge distinguished that rule for allocation from a right to contest the overall payment amount. The school district argued that its budget interest and its role as a recipient gave it standing. The court found those arguments did not show the type of legal injury needed to pursue this challenge.
The motion also raised whether the property owner had to be added to the proceeding. The judge found it unnecessary to decide the challenge on that basis after dismissing for lack of standing. The opinion observed that the owner was acting as lessor and that no allegation tied its existing lease rights to the amount of the project’s payments.
The ruling concerns the parties’ ability to bring this case. It does not amount to a new valuation of the battery project or a ruling that every aspect of an industrial development agency’s agreement would survive challenge by any party. The agency’s public meeting packet records a subsequent executive session over litigation strategy. The cited records do not establish whether another court has ruled on the merits.

