Blue Point fire district ran $3.4 million in operating surpluses over six years
The state comptroller questioned the district’s annual estimates and asked commissioners to adopt a plan for keeping and using reserves.
Blue Point Fire District budgets produced about $3.4 million in operating surpluses from 2019 through 2024, according to a financial management audit the state comptroller released July 24. The review concluded that the Board of Fire Commissioners did not effectively manage the district’s available balances or its capital reserves.
The audit focused on the relationship between the figures in budgets and the money the district ultimately needed. If actual operating costs are regularly lower than budgeted expenses, the difference can become a surplus at the end of the year. The state office said the board’s figures were not reasonable and concluded that property taxes may have been higher than necessary.
The largest annual gap in the six-year review came in 2024, when expenses fell $374,641 below the budgeted figure examined by state auditors. The report says spending fell short of estimates by more than 20 percent each year from 2020 through 2024. The district’s property tax levy increased from about $1.1 million in 2019 to $1.5 million in 2024 as it financed operations and added money to reserves.
Reserves matter in a fire district because equipment and buildings can require major expenditures that are difficult to absorb in one budget. An annual operating balance gives a district room to handle volatility. A capital reserve gives it a way to set aside money for planned projects. The board’s decisions about how much to retain in each need to be clear enough for future commissioners and taxpayers to understand.
Officials moved $2.4 million to four capital reserves during the six years, about $600,000 above what the board had budgeted for those transfers. At the end of 2024, the reserve funds together held about $1.6 million. That closing balance and the amount transferred over time measure different things. Comparing reserve balances with planned costs can show which future purchases the board expects them to finance.
The budget and reserve findings are related because operating surpluses made more money available for transfer. The comptroller called for better estimates and a written policy that would explain appropriate balances, how the district would fund the reserves and when it would spend them. An allocation that follows a schedule tied to specific capital costs produces a clearer record of the board’s intentions.
Auditors said the district lacked a policy that explained how much fund balance it intended to keep and how it planned to finance its reserves. In the absence of those policies, the office said some reserves may have been overfunded and the board’s intentions for surplus money were unclear. The $3.4 million is the cumulative amount produced by operations over the period, rather than a valuation of any one reserve account.
The report gives commissioners a basis for comparing prior forecasts with actual spending. Annual capital plans can also show whether a prospective equipment or facility purchase justifies the amount collected in advance. Together those records help explain why one year’s levy is set at a particular amount and what portion of earlier surpluses might be used to offset it.
The state repeated its findings in an Aug. 11 audit roundup. The report concerns the budgets it reviewed and the rules the board had in place during that period. Whether the district has changed its estimating practices or reserve policy is a subsequent question for its adopted budgets, public minutes and any corrective action plan.
