Appeals court restores Riverhead’s denial of cannabis shop variance
The Second Department upheld the commercial-corridor distinction and found a rational basis for denying this application.
The Second Department reversed a Suffolk County judgment in a dispute over a proposed Riverhead cannabis dispensary and left the town’s denial of a variance in place. The July 29, 2026 decision also directs entry of a declaration that one of Riverhead’s rules about proximity to residential property complies with New York’s zoning uniformity law.
Riverhead expanded the areas in which dispensaries could operate in a 2024 zoning amendment. Under the relevant rule, a dispensary site generally had to be at least 1,000 feet from a residential use property. The ordinance exempted qualifying parcels within five commercial corridors. The corridor at issue included certain properties with both frontage and vehicle access along a designated stretch of Old Country Road.
The Town Planning Department concluded that the proposed site fell within 1,000 feet of a residential property and outside the corridor. The applicants sought a variance, which the Zoning Board of Appeals denied in February 2025. Suffolk Supreme Court annulled the determination later that year and invalidated portions of the zoning ordinance.
The appeals court concluded that Riverhead could distinguish properties with direct frontage and access to the designated roads. It found a reasonable basis for that distinction despite different treatment of some properties in the same broader zoning district. It also held the board had a rational basis to deny the application, which the board and applicants had treated as a request for a use variance.
The opinion assumed for this application that the use-variance test was the proper one because both the board and the applicants had used it. That test asks an applicant to establish unnecessary hardship through evidence about reasonable return, unique property characteristics, the essential character of the neighborhood and whether the applicant created the hardship. The judges did not resolve whether every request under the same ordinance would necessarily use that standard.
The court found the applicants failed to demonstrate the hardship was not self-created. When they entered the lease, the code did not allow the proposed shop at that site without a variance. The judges also found that the board could weigh the close proximity of a single-family home and a residential neighborhood, together with the property’s lack of frontage on a designated corridor.
The court’s handling of the other spacing provision followed from that result. Once the court determined the proposed shop could not operate at this site under the residential-use rule and variance determination, a ruling on the distance between dispensaries would not affect the applicants’ right to open here. That is why the court reached a different disposition for the two rules addressed by the lower court.
The appeals court separately dismissed the challenge to the provision that measured distance between dispensaries. That procedural outcome matters when comparing the two judgments. The lower court had declared the provision invalid as preempted, and the appellate court did not replace that declaration with a merits ruling upholding a 2,500-foot buffer.
The result reinstates the original variance denial for this property and directs the lower court to enter the declaration about the residential-use rule. The official appellate and trial decisions record the different stages of the case.

