Center Moriches Fire District fell behind on annual financial reporting
New York’s comptroller found late independent audits and gaps in required filings. The two records serve different purposes.
The Center Moriches Fire District did not obtain timely annual audits or ensure that the treasurer filed all required annual reports with the state, the New York State Comptroller’s Office found in a report released Dec. 31. Auditors examined fiscal oversight from the end of 2019 through June 2025 and extended part of their review to Nov. 15, 2025.
The district’s outside accountant completed the audit for fiscal 2023 on Jan. 31, 2025, more than a year after that fiscal year ended. According to the state review, the fiscal 2024 external audit remained in progress on Nov. 15, 2025. Officials also could not show records of a competitive request for proposals for the accounting firm or an engagement letter laying out the services.
Under Town Law § 181-b, a fire district with at least $400,000 in revenue must obtain an independent audit annually. The law calls for a process that promotes competition in selecting the firm and limits an audit engagement to five years. An engagement letter gives the board a place to document what it hired the auditor to deliver.
By the end of the extended review, the treasurer had yet to file the reports for fiscal years 2020 through 2024. The report for 2019, the most recent one the state had received, was filed 122 days late. The lapse therefore covered five reporting years as of Nov. 15. In contrast, the outside accountant had generally completed the independent audits for 2019 through 2022 on time.
The annual financial report is a second obligation. General Municipal Law § 30 requires the treasurer to produce a public account of district finances and file it with the comptroller’s office. The district’s own filing can show revenue, expenditures and balances. An independent accountant’s work serves a separate purpose. Completing an outside audit alone would still leave a gap if the treasurer had not filed the annual report.
The state report explains that the financial report normally must be filed within 60 days of the end of the fire district’s fiscal year. An approved extension can give officials up to 120 days after year end. The finding on the five reports is about the status observed by the state on its cutoff date. It also reflects several older years for which even the longer timetable had passed.
Auditors made five recommendations. District officials agreed with the findings and recommendations and indicated they would begin corrective action. Town Law calls for a written plan to be sent to the state comptroller within 90 days. The state encouraged commissioners to make it publicly available.
The state office said delays impaired the ability of district residents, taxpayers and the board itself to assess the district’s finances. In a locally funded district, the timing matters. A financial record that arrives after officials have made another year’s budget decisions gives the public less opportunity to relate existing balances and expenditures to the next tax levy.
The public audit includes the district’s written response and the auditors’ methodology. The December report establishes when state auditors last checked the 2024 work and identifies the filing problems they found. The status of individual reports after that date would require confirmation from the state filing records and the district’s financial documents.
