Skip to content
Government

Southold rezoning challenge revived over voting and parkland claims

The appeals court reinstated key claims over a town-owned Peconic parcel and sent them back for further proceedings.

By Suffolk County Liberty Report Editorial DeskPublished
Montauk Point Lighthouse in Suffolk County, New York.
Contextual image. Montauk Point Lighthouse in Suffolk County, New York. Kevin Pepin. Image credits

An appeals court revived a challenge to the Town of Southold’s rezoning of a town-owned property in Peconic. On March 11, the Second Department reinstated claims that the Town Board needed a supermajority to pass the change and that prior actions may have dedicated the property to public park use.

Southold acquired the parcel in 2018. According to the decision, the board authorized $750,000 in bonds and described future town recreational use in the bond resolution. On April 11, 2023, the board adopted the rezoning by a vote of four to two and enacted it as Local Law 6-2023.

State Town Law generally allows zoning amendments by a simple majority. Section 265 requires approval by at least three-fourths of the Town Board in specified circumstances, including a written protest by owners of at least 20 percent of the area immediately adjacent to the property affected. The plaintiffs alleged that a protest by one adjacent landowner met that threshold.

The procedural threshold is important in a case disputing both the share of neighboring land represented by a protest and the legal status of a municipal parcel. On the town’s motion to dismiss, the appellate court assessed whether the pleadings stated supportable claims and whether the town’s own documents conclusively answered disputed facts. It ruled that the evidence submitted at that stage did not conclusively establish the town’s position on the adjacent parcel.

The appellate judges concluded that the town’s submissions did not conclusively rebut the allegations about the protester’s interest in the adjacent land. That allowed the supermajority challenge to proceed. The court separately revived the claim under the public trust doctrine, which restricts alienation of dedicated public parkland without state legislative approval.

The court distinguished formal dedication of parkland from dedication inferred from the treatment of a property. A deed restriction or legislative enactment can expressly identify land as a park. A record of continuous public use can support a different route to that conclusion. In this dispute, the language the town chose when borrowing to buy the property supported the challengers’ ability to pursue the claim.

The judges also looked to Southold’s code for context. The town’s definition of recreational areas includes parks, playgrounds and athletic fields. The appellate opinion treated that definition and the bond language as relevant to the adequacy of the pleading, leaving the effect of the full factual record for later proceedings.

The board’s reference to future recreation was part of the record the court examined. The March ruling decided whether the claims were sufficient to survive a motion to dismiss. It did not finally determine that the property was dedicated parkland or that the town counted votes incorrectly.

The Second Department returned the reinstated claims to Suffolk County Supreme Court. A later merits ruling would have to address the local voting record and the evidence concerning the town’s intended and actual treatment of the parcel.