Judge must read Huntington zoning memo before ruling on public access
The Second Department reinstated a records petition involving a memorandum from the Town Zoning Board of Appeals chair.
A Suffolk judge must privately examine a memorandum by Huntington’s zoning appeals chair before ruling on whether the town should disclose it, the Second Department decided Jan. 22, 2025. The appellate court reversed the dismissal of a Freedom of Information Law petition and sent it back for a new decision after review of the document.
The requester sought a memorandum dated May 27, 2020. The town relied in part on the exemption for material exchanged within or between agencies. The petitioner argued that the memorandum contained material that should be disclosed. In June 2021, Supreme Court denied his request for an in camera review, denied the petition and dismissed the proceeding.
The law’s internal-material exemption protects some candid discussions ahead of agency decisions. It expressly excludes certain kinds of information from that protection, including factual data. The presence of discussion or advice in a document does not necessarily resolve whether other portions can be disclosed. The contents needed to be evaluated before the judge could apply that exemption.
The appellate court held that it was premature to determine whether the memorandum was exempt without reading it. An in camera review lets a judge inspect an unredacted record outside public view. The procedure preserves confidentiality while the court decides whether an exemption applies and whether any parts should be released.
The January decision gives the petitioner another opportunity to have the disclosure claim decided. It does not itself release the memo or award attorneys’ fees. The new merits determination depends on what the judge finds in the document.

