Skip to content
Public Records

Suffolk law firm can challenge denial of traffic agency records

The Second Department ruled that making a request for a client did not erase the firm’s right to challenge its denial.

By Suffolk County Liberty Report Editorial DeskPublished
An illustration of a folder marked Public Records.
Contextual image. An illustration of a folder marked Public Records. Suffolk County Liberty Report. Image credits

A law firm that submitted a public records request to Suffolk’s Traffic and Parking Violations Agency had standing to challenge the denial even if the firm acted for a client, the Second Department ruled Nov. 22, 2023. The judges reversed the dismissal and returned the petition to Suffolk County Supreme Court for a decision on the merits.

The Law Offices of Cory H. Morris submitted the request in August 2018. The agency denied it in full. Among its reasons, the agency said certain records concerned its adjudicatory function. Its Freedom of Information Law appeals officer affirmed the result in November 2018, and the firm then brought an Article 78 proceeding.

The lower court ruled that the firm could not bring the case. The Second Department said the firm itself submitted the request, received a denial and pursued an administrative appeal. That was sufficient to challenge the administrative decision. A client’s ability to make a challenge did not displace the firm’s own interest as the unsuccessful requester.

The opinion resolves who may seek review of this request. The court did not decide whether the agency’s characterization of the requested material was correct or whether any exemption ultimately applied. It left those issues for the lower court on remand.

The ruling concerns the process for identifying the requester in court. A representative can submit a request in its own name and receive an agency decision that affects it. The separate questions of whether records exist and whether any statutory exception applies still have to be resolved on the underlying facts.