Babylon tree-house records case ends without legal fees
The court weighed what the village disclosed before the case and what a judge later ordered it to release.
A Babylon Village resident obtained unredacted complaints about his tree house during a public records case but was not entitled to legal fees, the Second Department ruled Aug. 14, 2024. The court considered how much the village released before suit, what was disclosed later and whether there was a reasonable basis to keep some material private.
The request grew out of village enforcement over alleged building code violations related to the tree house. In 2018, a village clerk assembled more than 1,000 pages for inspection. The village also released redacted copies of two complaints and said requested internal electronic messages were exempt under the Freedom of Information Law.
The resident later brought an Article 78 proceeding alleging an inadequate response and seeking fees. A 2021 appellate decision returned part of the dispute to Suffolk County Supreme Court for private judicial inspection. After that review, the judge ordered the complaints released in full and agreed that protected internal material in certain messages could remain redacted.
The later appeal turned on the fee provisions in Public Officers Law § 89. Those provisions consider whether a requester substantially prevailed and, for mandatory fees under one provision, whether the agency lacked a reasonable basis to deny access. The Second Department held that the lawsuit’s limited success did not meet the substantial-prevailing threshold.
The judges pointed to what the village made available before the proceeding and found a reasonable basis for its treatment of the remaining exempt messages. The ruling leaves the document disclosures made or ordered in the case intact. The question on appeal was whether the village also had to reimburse litigation expenses.

