Skip to content
Public Records

Newsday wins Suffolk police records appeal over discipline and 911 calls

The Second Department upheld disclosure subject to lawful redactions after police did not substantiate the exemptions they claimed.

By Suffolk County Liberty Report Editorial DeskPublished
An illustration of a folder marked Public Records.
Contextual image. An illustration of a folder marked Public Records. Suffolk County Liberty Report. Image credits

A state appeals court upheld an order requiring the Suffolk County Police Department to turn over certain disciplinary and 911-call records to Newsday, subject to lawful redactions and exemptions. The Oct. 2, 2024 ruling followed 10 requests the newspaper made from June 2020 to May 2021 under New York’s Freedom of Information Law.

The department withheld some records and produced others with redactions. Newsday went to Suffolk County Supreme Court after the administrative process. The lower court directed disclosure of certain categories of records in November 2023. The department appealed those aspects of the order.

The appellate judges rejected the department’s argument that disciplinary files could be withheld solely because the complaints were unsubstantiated, unfounded or ended in exoneration. After repeal of Civil Rights Law § 50-a, the state public records statute expressly includes complaints and allegations in its definition of law enforcement disciplinary records. The investigating agency’s conclusion remains important context for readers who see a complaint.

The court also considered the department’s privacy and life-or-safety arguments. Under the ruling, an agency must connect those exemptions to particular records with evidence. A general assertion that the material raises privacy or safety concerns does not supply the court with a basis for deciding what can legally be withheld.

The order affirmed on appeal preserved redactions and exemptions authorized by statute. That qualification is significant for both categories of records. A file can contain information the public is entitled to inspect and personal details the law permits an agency to remove. The appellate decision concerns the department’s disclosure duties and does not make findings about the underlying allegations.