Skip to content
Public Records

Suffolk employee directory dispute returns to court for a closer look

The Second Department found unresolved questions about whether county information technology staff could produce some of the requested records.

By Suffolk County Liberty Report Editorial DeskPublished
An illustration of a folder marked Public Records.
Contextual image. An illustration of a folder marked Public Records. Suffolk County Liberty Report. Image credits

A reporter’s effort to obtain a Suffolk County employee telephone directory survived dismissal on March 12, 2025. The Second Department reinstated the Freedom of Information Law case and sent it back to Suffolk County Supreme Court to determine which responsive records, if any, the county Information Technology Department possessed.

The reporter first asked for an electronic export of county employee directory information in 2021. In an administrative appeal, he clarified that he wanted the employee telephone directory. The county maintained that the IT department did not maintain the requested record, and Supreme Court concluded the law did not require the county to create one.

The appellate judges focused on a county employee’s affidavit. In their view, the county’s own account raised questions about whether some of the requested information could be identified, located and produced. That made it premature to end the case on the theory that the county had no responsive material.

New York’s law generally does not require an agency to create new data to satisfy a request. It does address retrieval of data already maintained electronically. The distinction can affect cases in which a requester describes an export or list, and the agency organizes the underlying information differently from the way the requester describes it.

The court did not order delivery of a complete telephone directory or determine which data must ultimately be disclosed. It held that further proceedings were needed to identify the records that might exist. The reporter’s request for fees and litigation costs remained premature because the petition had yet to be decided.