Skip to content
Public Records

Suffolk traffic agency’s search certification ends challenge over summons records

The appeals court accepted the county’s certification that it had produced responsive records and found no others after a diligent search.

By Suffolk County Liberty Report Editorial DeskPublished
An illustration of a folder marked Public Records.
Contextual image. An illustration of a folder marked Public Records. Suffolk County Liberty Report. Image credits

A state appellate panel found that Suffolk County’s Traffic and Parking Violations Agency met its obligations on a request for records tied to a speeding summons. The April 16, 2025 ruling affirmed the dismissal of the branches of the case seeking more records and attorneys’ fees.

The requester received a ticket in January 2021 and asked for documents related to it in May 2022. The agency provided some records in July. The requester appealed administratively, saying the response was partial, and did not identify any specific missing document, according to the decision.

The County Attorney’s Office responded in August with a records officer’s certification that the agency had produced all responsive records it possessed. The certification said the agency had no additional responsive records or could not locate them after a diligent search. The appellate court held that this satisfied the agency’s obligation on the facts before it.

New York’s public records law lets a requester seek a certification when an agency does not possess a record or cannot find it after a diligent search. The certification addresses the agency’s ability to produce the record. It is different from an exemption, which is a legal justification an agency may invoke when it holds material but says it may withhold it.

The judges held that the requester had not substantially prevailed and therefore was not entitled to fees. The decision concerned the records made available for that request. It did not decide whether the underlying speeding ticket should have been issued.