Court upholds Suffolk’s response timetable for a high-volume records request
The Second Department weighed the amount of requested material and the need to review records that were kept on paper.
Suffolk County
Long Island
New York
and beyond
Reporting on public access, court documents, transparency, and New York’s Freedom of Information Law.
The Second Department weighed the amount of requested material and the need to review records that were kept on paper.
The appeals court accepted the county’s certification that it had produced responsive records and found no others after a diligent search.
The ruling concerns what a judge may examine in a civil lawsuit, a different procedure from ordering public release.
The Second Department found unresolved questions about whether county information technology staff could produce some of the requested records.
The Second Department reinstated a records petition involving a memorandum from the Town Zoning Board of Appeals chair.
The Second Department upheld disclosure subject to lawful redactions after police did not substantiate the exemptions they claimed.
The court weighed what the village disclosed before the case and what a judge later ordered it to release.
The Second Department ruled that making a request for a client did not erase the firm’s right to challenge its denial.